Tuesday, November 17, 2026

More Parties in Government

No reflection this week, but before you take off for Thanksgiving, write one on what you learned during the past three class sessions (Nov 16, 18, 23).

For Monday:


Review from Sept 2o:

As of Jan 2027, Trump states with Democratic governors

StateGovernor2026 result
AlaskaJonathan Kreiss-TomkinsDemocratic pickup
ArizonaKatie HobbsDemocratic hold
GeorgiaKeisha Lance BottomsDemocratic pickup
IowaRob SandDemocratic pickup
KansasCindy HolscherDemocratic hold
KentuckyAndy BeshearNo election
MichiganJocelyn BensonDemocratic hold
NevadaAaron FordDemocratic pickup
North CarolinaJosh SteinNo election
OhioAmy ActonDemocratic pickup
PennsylvaniaJosh ShapiroDemocratic hold
TexasGina HinojosaDemocratic pickup
WisconsinDavid CrowleyDemocratic hold

All six Democratic gubernatorial pickups in 2026 came in Trump states. Democratic governors will also lead all seven of the 2024 presidential battleground states. californiatoday.com

Harris states with Republican governors

StateGovernor    2026 result
New HampshireKelly Ayotte    Reelected
VermontPhil Scott    Reelected

Massachusetts has had a bunch of Republican govenors:

  • John A. Volpe 1965–1969
  • Francis W. Sargent 1969–1975
  • William F. Weld 1991–1997
  • Paul Cellucci 1997–2001
  • Jane Swift 2001–2003 (acting governor)
  • Mitt Romney 2003–2007
  • Charlie Baker 2015–2023
How do they run for governor?  What issues prevail?  What powers do they have once they win?  And what dangers do they face when they win?

Running for Senate is different

From 1990 through 2026, sitting and former governors went 2–12 in U.S. Senate races in states that leaned clearly toward the other party. The only winners were Ben Nelson in Nebraska in 2000 and Joe Manchin in West Virginia in 2010, both Democrats. . ballotpedia.org

The opposing party had to lead by more than 12 percentage points on average across the two most recent presidential elections, including a same-day presidential election where applicable. The count covers major-party nominees running without Senate incumbency. electionlab.mit.edu

YearStateGovernor or former governorSenate result
1994WyomingMike Sullivan (D)Lost to Craig Thomas
1996MassachusettsBill Weld (R)Lost to John Kerry
1996NebraskaBen Nelson (D)Lost to Chuck Hagel
2000NebraskaBen Nelson (D)Won against Don Stenberg
2002OklahomaDavid Walters (D)Lost to Jim Inhofe
2004AlaskaTony Knowles (D)Lost to Lisa Murkowski
2008MississippiRonnie Musgrove (D)Lost to Roger Wicker
2010West VirginiaJoe Manchin (D)Won against John Raese
2012HawaiiLinda Lingle (R)Lost to Mazie Hirono
2012NebraskaBob Kerrey (D)Lost to Deb Fischer
2016IndianaEvan Bayh (D)Lost to Todd Young
2018TennesseePhil Bredesen (D)Lost to Marsha Blackburn
2020MontanaSteve Bullock (D)Lost to Steve Daines
2024MarylandLarry Hogan (R)Lost to Angela Alsobrooks


The Courts

SCOTUS politics was pretty partisan in the 19th century.  Lincoln's 1858 "House Divided" speech included ... conspiracy theory

We cannot absolutely know that all these exact adaptations are the result of preconcert. But when we see a lot of framed timbers, different potions of which we know have been gotten out at different times and places and by different workmen,- Stephen, Franklin, Roger and James, for instance-and we see these timbers joined together, and see they exactly make the frame of a house or a mill, all the tenons and mortieses exactly fitting, and all the lengths and proportions of the different pieces exactly adapted to their respective places, and not a piece too many or too few-not omitting even scaffolding-or, if a single piece be lacking, we see the place in the frame exactly fitted and prepared to yet bring such piece in-in such a case, we find it impossible not to believe that Stephen and Franklin and Roger and James all understood one another from the beginning, and all worked upon a common plan or draft drawn up before the first lick was struck.

In the 20th century, SCOTUS was not consistently part of presidential politics until the 1960s.



Nixon 1968 (at about 19:30)





Clarence Thomas
Note who presided over his confirmation hearing:






On a hopeful note ... our guy!!!

Sunday, November 15, 2026

State and Local Elections, Parties in Government

For Wednesday, Hershey ch. 14

Visual depiction of change in the House

Party Unity 

From Roll Call:

2025 data, from Roll Call, 2026:


Why is party unity so high?

Change in constituencies -- gerrymandering is only part of the answer.  Until 2026, crossover districts had been waning:

Primaries  -- defeats are rare but many retire first

On David Frum's podcast, former Rep. Bob Inglis (D-SC) explained why losing a primary really hurts.

That's the worst. It's not quite so bad when you lose a general. I had suffered the ignominy of losing a primary.

That's where literally people that have told you that they love you, they're praying for you, they hug you around the neck. Next time you see them, they've got the other guy's sticker on them. That's really painful.

Now, if you lose a general, it's not quite so bad because they'll invite you to speak at the next Lincoln dinner because you fought the good fight against the blue enemy and your loss came up short, but you fought the good fight. When you lose in a primary though, which is explains why people are so afraid of losing primaries, there's no invitation to the Lincoln Day dinner because you've now a person without a home, you literally been divorced from the party. That's why I think so many have been so fearful of losing those primaries.”

House Republicans chose to go farther to the right.

CROSS-PRESSURE: On the Democratic side, the majority makers are closer to the center:


Nine new D Senators from states Trump carried in 2024:

  • Alaska Mary Peltola
  • Iowa Josh Turek
  • Kansas Adam Hamilton
  • Michigan Abdul El-Sayed 
  • Mississippi Scott Colom
  • North Carolina Roy Cooper
  • Ohio Sherrod Brown
  • South Carolina Annie Andrews
  • Texas James Talarico
Incumbent Democrats from Trump states
  • Arizona: Gallego & Kelly
  • Georgia: Ossoff & Warnock
  • Michigan: Slotkin
  • Nevada: Cortez Masto & Rosen
  • Pennsylvania:  Fetterman
No Republican senator will represent a Harris state.

State Legislatures

In California, how state legislators can lose:


So what does a party do when it has near-total control of state and local government?  See this video, start at 2:00


Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Presentations

For this week's write-up, briefly discuss someone else's class presentation.  What did you learn, and why is it important?

For Monday, read: 

  • Carson, ch. 7
  • Hershey, ch. 13



Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Well-Done

For the write-up, what outcome surprised you the most and why?

Next week, everyone will give a brief talk on the research paper.  Prepare to speak for 5 minutes and take questions for 2-3 minutes on these questions:

  • What is the main point you are making?
  • What evidence are you using?
  • Are you looking for additional evidence?  If so, what kind?
If you want to display a graph, table, map, or photo, email it to me by the night before class, so I can post it on the blog.  You do not need a PowerPoint just to repeat what you are saying.

Here is the schedule.  You may swap slots, but tell me in advance.

Monday:
  • Peter
  • Nick C.
  • Lily
  • Kurt
  • Jasper
  • Dean
  • Isaiah
  • Sohani
Wednesday:

  • Charlie
  • Keith
  • Chantal
  • Omar
  • Emily
  • Nicholas S.
  • Thea

WELL-DONE SCENARIO: Dems gain an astounding 43 House seats (NYT estimate) and at least 7 Senate seats, and maybe 9.




Specific races:
  • Kurt: KY 6
  • Charlie: NY 17
  • Keith: TX 15
Bigger picture: nationalization of elections

Iran war: 
Energy: 

Inflation: 
Tariffs: 
Data centers: 
Immigration: 
Four Strategic Postures Since 2000 (House, by election year) 

                    Majority                              Minority 

In Party        Dems 08, 20                     GOP 06, 18, 26
                    GOP 00, 02, 04, 16, 24      Dem 10,12,14,22
           
Out Party     GOP 10,12,14,22              GOP 08, 20
                    Dem 06, 18, 26                  Dem 00, 02, 04, 16, 24

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Election Eve

For tonight, post a short summary of what you expect to find in your paper.

Next week, everybody will make a short oral presentation (7-10 minutes).  We shall go in alphabetical order unless you request otherwise.  PowerPoints not necessary unless you want to show a map, table, or graph.  Email it to me first, and I will post to the blog.

For Wednesday, chapter 6 of Carson and Jacobson.

Scenarios

Election Night (all times Eastern, so subtract 3)

From Bruce Mehlman P `25









Party-line voting 







"Waves" and "Snapbacks"

Why the difference between House and Senate outcomes?

What happened in "wave" years?




Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Congressional Campaigns: Money, Strategy, Media Tactics

 Questions on the paper?  Remember, each of you will make a brief (10-minute max) presentation the week after next.  (Use PowerPoint only if you have tables or graphs.)

Early vote tracker, NOT a foolproof indicator of the outcome.


For Monday,  Carson & Jacobson, ch. 5

Why run?
Campaign Finance Redux:  Access Money and Belief Money
Campaign Strategy and  Message Grid

Oppo and vulnerability studies:  "Dirty Tricks Thursday" and early voting

Base mobilization  
Demobilization
Persuasion

Monday, October 26, 2026

Research Paper

Option 1

National forces shape congressional elections. But why do similar candidates fare differently?

Choose two House candidates from the same party whose 2026 results present a puzzle. One might win while the other loses, or one might outperform the party’s usual showing while the other falls short. Do not use a race from your previous paper.

Before the election, choose a provisional pair in your weekly writeup, due this time on November 2.   Include the note in your final appendix; no separate submission is necessary. You may change your pair afterward, but tell why.

After the election, establish the puzzle. Consider district partisanship, incumbency, candidate experience, and spending. Set a baseline for judging performance. A victory alone does not show that a candidate exceeded expectations.

Test two competing explanations for the difference. Find evidence that helps distinguish them. Do not assume a tactic worked because its candidate won.

Build your argument around three findings:

  • A campaign contrast: Compare the items you saved. Quote or describe a specific feature that bears on your explanation.

  • A local complication: Find a fact in local reporting or official records that a national account of the election might miss. Explain whether it changes your argument.

  • An inconvenient fact: Present the strongest evidence against your preferred explanation. Explain why it matters.

Use official returns, campaign materials, local reporting, and course readings. Cite exact pages, passages, or figures where appropriate. If returns remain incomplete, explain what you can and cannot conclude.

Return to your Canvas note. Identify what you got wrong, overlooked, or confirmed. Explain which source most changed your thinking.

Conclude by weighing national forces against individual campaigns. State what your comparison cannot establish.


Option 2

Whatever happens, the 2026 election will change Trump’s political circumstances. Will it change how he governs?

Choose one policy goal Trump emphasized before the election. Explain how the results affect his options: seek legislation, act through executive authority, negotiate, or delay.  Describe your  choice in your weekly writeup, this time due November 2.

Save two pre-election statements showing what Trump wanted and how he planned to get it. Then examine his statements and actions after the election, through November 18. Did he change his goal, his methods, or just his message? Consider the congressional results, party divisions, and limits on presidential power.

Identify his most plausible next moves. Explain its chief obstacle and weigh the strongest alternative. Tell what evidence would change your judgment. Distinguish actions from announcements and threats. Assess what Trump can do, not what you wish he would do.

Evidence: Use Trump’s statements before and after the election, relevant executive actions or bills, congressional responses, election results, and independent reporting. Include evidence that challenges your argument.


Option 3

Political parties have official leaders. On social media, other people may command more attention.

Choose one issue contested in the 2026 election. Compare how three accounts on the same platform address it: an official party account, a candidate or elected official, and an independent commentator aligned with that party.  Do not choose Trump's accounts. Describe your choice in your weekly writeup, this time due November 2.

Collect twelve public posts—two from each account before the election and two afterward, through November 18. Use the same date ranges for all three accounts. Explain how you selected the posts; do not simply choose the most outrageous examples.

Who defines the issue? Who identifies enemies, sets priorities, or tells followers what the election means? Examine humor, images, emotional appeals, and calls to action. Identify one revealing disagreement or difference in emphasis. Then assess whether the election changed the accounts’ messages or their relationship to the party.

Use course readings and outside research to explain what your comparison reveals about party organization, polarization, or governing. Distinguish evidence of influence from evidence of attention: likes and shares alone do not show that an account changed votes or policy.

Conclude by answering: Does social media help party leaders direct their coalition, or give them a coalition they cannot control? Address the strongest evidence against your answer.

Evidence: Include a compact appendix with the twelve posts, dates, links, and brief descriptions. Trace one apparent instance of influence (e.g.,  another account adopting a phrase or responding to a demand) and consider whether a shared news event offers a better explanation. Choose publicly accessible accounts.

Option 4

Americans increasingly vote for state and local offices as they vote for president. Do state and local races still turn on state and local concerns?

Pick one state or local race on the November ballot, in any state: governor, state legislature, attorney general, secretary of state, state supreme court, mayor, county office, or a statewide ballot measure. Your home state is a good choice. Ballotpedia lists races by state.  In your weekly writeup, this time due November 2, predict who will win and whether the race will turn on local issues or national ones. Use sources such as

  • Candidate or campaign websites, ads, and social media posts
  • Party endorsements and spending, state and national
  • Campaign finance records (your state’s disclosure site or FollowTheMoney.org)
  • Endorsements from interest groups and elected officials
  • Local news coverage, through the college library’s databases
  • Official results if available
Answer these questions:

  • What did each side say the race was about? 
  • Where did the money come from: in state or out of state, parties or groups?
  • Did the national party help, ignore, or embarrass its candidate?
  • Did the results follow the national tide, or depart from it? Compare the race to statewide or national results.
  • If the race is undecided on November 18, say so and reason from the count so far.
  • Was your November 1 prediction right?  Why or why not?

Requirements

  • Essays should be double-spaced, 12-point type, and no more than six pages long. I will not read past the sixth page.
  • Essays should be in Word document format. Do not submit PDFs.
  • Cite all outside sources with endnotes (not footnotes) in Chicago/Turabian style. Endnote pages do not count against the page limit.
  • Misrepresenting AI-generated content as your own work is plagiarism. It could result in a referral to the Academic Standards Committee.
  • Watch your spelling, grammar, diction, and punctuation. Errors will count against you. Read Strunk & White and watch my writing lecture before writing this paper.
  • Turn in essays to Canvas by 11:59 PM, Friday, November 20. (If you have trouble with Canvas, simply email it to me as a Word file.) I reserve the right to dock essays a grade point for one day’s lateness, a full letter grade after that.
Option 5.  If the previous four do not inspire you, devise your own topic, subject to my approval.  Please do so before Election Day.